Bills — Aged Care Bill 2024; in Committee
Fatima Payman voted Yes
Karen Grogan voted No
Passed by a modest majority
No rebellions 75% attendance
Fatima Payman and Karen Grogan have voted the same way 94% of the time
Fatima Payman
Independent Senator for WA since July 2024
Karen Grogan
Australian Labor Party Senator for SA since September 2021
Since May 2022 Fatima Payman and Karen Grogan have voted in the same division 856 times.
In divisions they have voted the same 807 times. They have only voted differently 49 times.
How do their votes on policies compare?
Policies are groups of votes related to an issue. We only show policies where we have enough information on both people.
Voted a mixture of the same and differently on
- Considering motions on Gaza (2023-24) (procedural)
- Implementing refugee and protection conventions
- Increasing accessibility of government data and documents
- Protecting threatened forest and bushland habitats
- Speeding things along in Parliament (procedural)
- Suspending the rules to allow a vote to happen (procedural)
Always voted the same way on
- A character test for Australian visas
- A referendum on the Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Voice
- An Australian Building and Construction Commission (ABCC)
- Australia's timber industry
- Banning new thermal coal mines
- Banning pay secrecy clauses
- Capping gas prices
- Compulsory income management for welfare recipients
- Decreasing subsidisation of fossil fuels
- Encouraging Australian-based industry
- Ending government investment in fossil fuels
- Ending immigration detention on Nauru
- Ending indexation on student debt (vocational and tertiary)
- Federal action on public housing
- Federal government action on animal & plant extinctions
- Fee-free university and TAFE education
- Increasing Aboriginal land rights
- Increasing access to medicinal cannabis products
- Increasing housing affordability
- Increasing legal protections for LGBTI people
- Increasing political transparency
- Increasing protection of Australia's fresh water
- Increasing transparency of big business by making information public
- Increasing workplace protections
- Introducing a Pacific Engagement Visa (PEV)
- Live animal export
- Market-led approaches to protecting biodiversity
- More scrutiny of intelligence services & police
- Net zero emissions by 2035
- Net zero emissions by 2050
- No new fossil fuels projects
- Nuclear energy
- Political intervention in research funding grants
- Preventative Detention Orders (PDOs)
- Procedural fairness
- Protecting whistleblowers
- Reducing taxes for high-income earners
- Repealing Stage 3 tax cuts
- Requiring Parliamentary approval of military deployments
- Restricting donations to political parties
- Revoking citizenship of dual nationals involved with terrorism offences by the courts
- Self-governance of the territories
- The federal government calling for a ceasefire in Gaza (2023-24)
- The Paris Climate Agreement
- The territories being able to legalise euthanasia
- Transgender children and young people having access to gender affirming healthcare
- Transgender rights
- Treating COVID vaccine status as a protected attribute
- Unconventional gas mining
- Vehicle efficiency standards
Divisions in which they voted differently
In divisions they have voted the same 807 times. They have only voted differently 49 times.
-
-
Bills — Aged Care Bill 2024; in Committee
Fatima Payman voted Yes
Karen Grogan voted No
Passed by a modest majority
No rebellions 78% attendance
-
Bills — Aged Care Bill 2024; in Committee
Fatima Payman voted Yes
Karen Grogan voted No
Not passed by a small majority
No rebellions 51% attendance
-
Bills — Aged Care Bill 2024, Aged Care Legislation Amendment Bill 2024; Second Reading
Fatima Payman voted Yes
Karen Grogan voted No
Not passed by a modest majority
No rebellions 58% attendance
-
Matters of Urgency — Aukus
Fatima Payman voted Yes
Karen Grogan voted No
Not passed by a modest majority
No rebellions 50% attendance
-
Committees — Legal and Constitutional Affairs References Committee; Reference
Fatima Payman voted Yes
Karen Grogan voted No
Not passed by a small majority
No rebellions 57% attendance
-
Committees — Environment and Communications References Committee; Reference
Fatima Payman voted Yes
Karen Grogan voted No
Not passed by a small majority
No rebellions 57% attendance
-
Documents — Housing; Order for the Production of Documents
Fatima Payman voted Yes
Karen Grogan voted No
Passed by a modest majority
No rebellions 87% attendance
-
Documents — Australian Prudential Regulation Authority; Order for the Production of Documents
Fatima Payman voted Yes
Karen Grogan voted No
Not passed by a small majority
No rebellions 84% attendance
-
Bills — Electoral Legislation Amendment (Electoral Reform) Bill 2024, Electoral Legislation Amendment (Electoral Communications) Bill 2024; Reference to Committee
Fatima Payman voted Yes
Karen Grogan voted No
Not passed by a modest majority
No rebellions 74% attendance
-
Documents — Rural and Regional Affairs and Transport References Committee; Order for the Production of Documents
Fatima Payman voted Yes
Karen Grogan voted No
Passed by a modest majority
No rebellions 87% attendance
-
Committees — Legal and Constitutional Affairs Legislation Committee; Reference
Fatima Payman voted Yes
Karen Grogan voted No
Not passed by a modest majority
No rebellions 61% attendance
-
edited 13th Oct 2024
Australian Naval Nuclear Power Safety Bill 2024 and another - Third Reading - Agree with the remaining stages
Fatima Payman voted No, rebelling against the Australian Labor Party
Karen Grogan voted Yes
Passed by a small majority
1 rebellion 54% attendance
-
edited 20th Oct 2024
Australian Naval Nuclear Power Safety Bill 2024 and another - Committee of the Whole - Objects and Register of Nuclear Power Safety
Fatima Payman voted Yes, rebelling against the Australian Labor Party
Karen Grogan voted No
Not passed by a small majority
1 rebellion 50% attendance
-
edited 20th Oct 2024
Australian Naval Nuclear Power Safety Bill 2024 and another - Committee of the Whole - Operation of State and Territory laws
Fatima Payman voted No, rebelling against the Australian Labor Party
Karen Grogan voted Yes
Passed by a small majority
1 rebellion 54% attendance
-
edited 20th Oct 2024
Australian Naval Nuclear Power Safety Bill 2024 and another - Committee of the Whole - Nuclear safety incidents and prohibiting radioactive waste under certain circumstances
Fatima Payman voted Yes, rebelling against the Australian Labor Party
Karen Grogan voted No
Not passed by a small majority
1 rebellion 53% attendance
-
edited 20th Oct 2024
Australian Naval Nuclear Power Safety Bill 2024 and another - Committee of the Whole - Nuclear safety duties, liability of commonwealth for contractors, UNDRIP, fit and proper p...
Fatima Payman voted Yes, rebelling against the Australian Labor Party
Karen Grogan voted No
Not passed by a modest majority
1 rebellion 54% attendance
-
edited 20th Oct 2024
Australian Naval Nuclear Power Safety Bill 2024 and another - Committee of the Whole - Functions to be performed having regard to prescribed international agreements
Fatima Payman voted No, rebelling against the Australian Labor Party
Karen Grogan voted Yes
Passed by a small majority
1 rebellion 55% attendance
-
edited 20th Oct 2024
Australian Naval Nuclear Power Safety Bill 2024 and another - Committee of the Whole - Australian Greens amendments
Fatima Payman voted Yes, rebelling against the Australian Labor Party
Karen Grogan voted No
Not passed by a small majority
1 rebellion 55% attendance
-
edited 20th Oct 2024
Australian Naval Nuclear Power Safety Bill 2024 and another - Second Reading - Agree with the bills' main idea
Fatima Payman voted No, rebelling against the Australian Labor Party
Karen Grogan voted Yes
Passed by a small majority
2 rebellions 57% attendance
-
edited 20th Oct 2024
Crimes and Other Legislation Amendment (Omnibus No. 1) Bill 2024 - in Committee - When NACC hearing may be held in public
Fatima Payman voted Yes, rebelling against the Australian Labor Party
Karen Grogan voted No
Not passed by a small majority
2 rebellions 58% attendance
-
edited 29 days ago
Documents - Department of Social Services; Order for the Production of Documents - Non-disclosure agreements
Fatima Payman voted Yes, rebelling against the Australian Labor Party
Karen Grogan voted No
Passed by a modest majority
1 rebellion 78% attendance
-
Committees — Selection of Bills Committee; Report
Fatima Payman voted Yes, rebelling against the Australian Labor Party
Karen Grogan voted No
Not passed by a small majority
1 rebellion 82% attendance
-
Committees — Selection of Bills Committee; Report
Fatima Payman voted Yes, rebelling against the Australian Labor Party
Karen Grogan voted No
Not passed by a small majority
1 rebellion 58% attendance
-
Documents — Rural and Regional Affairs and Transport References Committee; Order for the Production of Documents
Fatima Payman voted Yes, rebelling against the Australian Labor Party
Karen Grogan voted No
Passed by a modest majority
1 rebellion 75% attendance
-
Documents — Department of the Treasury; Order for the Production of Documents
Fatima Payman voted Yes, rebelling against the Australian Labor Party
Karen Grogan voted No
Passed by a modest majority
1 rebellion 75% attendance
-
Documents — Department of the Treasury; Order for the Production of Documents
Fatima Payman voted Yes, rebelling against the Australian Labor Party
Karen Grogan voted No
Passed by a modest majority
1 rebellion 76% attendance
-
edited 13th Oct 2024
Motions - Israel Attacks: First Anniversary - Greens motion
Fatima Payman voted Yes, rebelling against the Australian Labor Party
Karen Grogan voted No
Not passed by a modest majority
1 rebellion 76% attendance
-
edited 28 days ago
Motions - Israel Attacks: First Anniversary - Australia's social cohesion
Fatima Payman voted No, rebelling against the Australian Labor Party
Karen Grogan voted Yes
Passed by a modest majority
1 rebellion 80% attendance
-
edited 13th Oct 2024
Competition and Consumer Amendment (Make Price Gouging Illegal) Bill 2024 - Second Reading - Agree with the bill's main idea
Fatima Payman voted Yes, rebelling against the Australian Labor Party
Karen Grogan voted No
Not passed by a small majority
1 rebellion 59% attendance
-
Business — Rearrangement
Fatima Payman voted Yes, rebelling against the Australian Labor Party
Karen Grogan voted No
Passed by a modest majority
1 rebellion 82% attendance
-
edited 22 days ago
Competition and Consumer Amendment (Make Price Gouging Illegal) Bill 2024 - Second Reading - Refer to committee
Fatima Payman voted No, rebelling against the Australian Labor Party
Karen Grogan voted Yes
Not passed by a modest majority
1 rebellion 78% attendance
-
edited 22 days ago
Competition and Consumer Amendment (Make Price Gouging Illegal) Bill 2024 - Second Reading - Put the question
Fatima Payman voted Yes, rebelling against the Australian Labor Party
Karen Grogan voted No
Passed by a modest majority
1 rebellion 78% attendance
-
edited 13th Oct 2024
Motions - Gambling Advertising - Ban
Fatima Payman voted Yes, rebelling against the Australian Labor Party
Karen Grogan voted No
Not passed by a small majority
2 rebellions 54% attendance
-
edited 5th Oct 2024
Documents - Attorney-General's Department - Order for the Production of Documents
Fatima Payman voted Yes, rebelling against the Australian Labor Party
Karen Grogan voted No
Passed by a modest majority
1 rebellion 74% attendance
-
edited 28th Sep 2024
Documents - Health Care: Private Hospital Sector Financial Health Check - Order for the Production of Documents
Fatima Payman voted Yes, rebelling against the Australian Labor Party
Karen Grogan voted No
Passed by a small majority
1 rebellion 80% attendance
-
edited 20th Sep 2024
Motions - Middle East: Casualties - Let a vote take place
Fatima Payman voted Yes, rebelling against the Australian Labor Party
Karen Grogan voted No
Not passed by a small majority
1 rebellion 46% attendance
-
edited 5th Oct 2024
Documents - Department of Home Affairs - Order for the Production of Documents
Fatima Payman voted Yes, rebelling against the Australian Labor Party
Karen Grogan voted No
Passed by a modest majority
1 rebellion 86% attendance
-
edited 15th Sep 2024
Ending Native Forest Logging Bill 2023 - Second Reading - Agree with the bill's main idea
Fatima Payman voted Yes, rebelling against the Australian Labor Party
Karen Grogan voted No
Not passed by a modest majority
1 rebellion 57% attendance
-
edited 29th Sep 2024
Regulations and Determinations - Work Health and Safety (Operation Sovereign Borders) Declaration 2024 - Disallowance
Fatima Payman voted Yes, rebelling against the Australian Labor Party
Karen Grogan voted No
Not passed by a small majority
1 rebellion 54% attendance
-
edited 24th Aug 2024
Matters of Urgency - Education - Over-funding of private schools
Fatima Payman voted Yes, rebelling against the Australian Labor Party
Karen Grogan voted No
Not passed by a modest majority
1 rebellion 49% attendance
-
edited 6th Oct 2024
Documents - Australian Human Rights Commission - Order for the Production of Documents
Fatima Payman voted Yes, rebelling against the Australian Labor Party
Karen Grogan voted No
Not passed by a modest majority
1 rebellion 53% attendance
-
Motions — Equal Pay Day
Fatima Payman voted Yes, rebelling against the Australian Labor Party
Karen Grogan voted No
Not passed by a modest majority
1 rebellion 47% attendance
-
Motions — Equal Pay Day
Fatima Payman voted No, rebelling against the Australian Labor Party
Karen Grogan voted Yes
Passed by a modest majority
1 rebellion 47% attendance
-
edited 17th Aug 2024
Regulations and Determinations - Migration Amendment (Visa Application Charges) Regulations 2024 - Disallow
Fatima Payman voted Yes, rebelling against the Australian Labor Party
Karen Grogan voted No
Not passed by a modest majority
1 rebellion 50% attendance
-
edited 17th Aug 2024
Matters of Urgency - Gambling Advertising - Ban
Fatima Payman voted Yes, rebelling against the Australian Labor Party
Karen Grogan voted No
Not passed by a small majority
2 rebellions 51% attendance
-
edited 17th Aug 2024
Motions - Middle East - Let a vote on Palestine take place
Fatima Payman voted Yes, rebelling against the Australian Labor Party
Karen Grogan voted No
Not passed by a modest majority
1 rebellion 61% attendance
-
edited 17th Aug 2024
Motions - Middle East - Put the question
Fatima Payman voted No, rebelling against the Australian Labor Party
Karen Grogan voted Yes
Passed by a modest majority
1 rebellion 62% attendance
-
edited 3rd Jul 2024
Matters of Urgency - Middle East: Occupied Palestinian Territories - Recognise the State of Palestine
Fatima Payman voted Yes, rebelling against the Australian Labor Party
Karen Grogan voted No
Not passed by a modest majority
1 rebellion 86% attendance