2nd Sep 2020, 4:29 PM – Representatives Motions - Covid-19: Aged Care - Don't let another vote take place
Summary
EditThe majority voted in favour of disagreeing with a motion introduced by Franklin MP Julie Collins (Labor), which means it failed. The motion was to suspend the usual procedural rules - known as standing orders - so that another vote could take place. Since it failed, that second vote won't happen.
Motion text
That so much of the standing orders be suspended as would prevent the Member for Franklin from moving the following motion immediately—That the House:
(1) notes:
(a) comments from Tony Abbott reported today that suggest the families of older Australians with COVID-19 should just "let nature take its course";
(b) the Prime Minister has previously said comments like this are "amoral" and "hideous";
(c) the Minister for Aged Care and Senior Australians was willing to condemn Mr Abbott's comments, but given the opportunity, the Prime Minister refused;
(d) the Prime Minister's moral standards do not seem to extend to former Liberal Prime Ministers; and
(e) comments like Mr Abbott's must be condemned in the strongest possible terms; and
(2) invites the Prime Minister to make a statement in this House on this matter immediately.
Votes Passed by a small majority
Nobody rebelled against their party.
Party | Votes | |
---|---|---|
Adam Bandt Melbourne Australian Greens | Absent | |
Australian Labor Party (47% turnout) | 0 Yes – 32 No | |
Anthony Albanese Grayndler | No | |
Anne Aly Cowan | No | |
Chris Bowen McMahon | No | |
Tony Burke Watson | No | |
Linda Burney Barton | No | |
Mark Butler Hindmarsh | No | |
Terri Butler Griffith | No | |
Lisa Chesters Bendigo | No | |
Jason Clare Blaxland | No | |
Julie Collins Franklin | No | |
Justine Elliot Richmond | No | |
Joel Fitzgibbon Hunter | No | |
Mike Freelander Macarthur | No | |
Andrew Giles Scullin | No | |
Chris Hayes Fowler | No | |
Stephen Jones Whitlam | No | |
Andrew Leigh Fenner | No | |
Kristy McBain Eden-Monaro | No | |
Emma McBride Dobell | No | |
Brian Mitchell Lyons | No | |
Peta Murphy Dunkley | No | |
Brendan O'Connor Gorton | No | |
Julie Owens Parramatta | No | |
Fiona Phillips Gilmore | No | |
Tanya Plibersek Sydney | No | |
Amanda Rishworth Kingston | No | |
Warren Snowdon Lingiari | No | |
Anne Stanley Werriwa | No | |
Meryl Swanson Paterson | No | |
Susan Templeman Macquarie | No | |
Tim Watts Gellibrand | No | |
Josh Wilson Fremantle | No | |
Sharon Bird Cunningham | Absent | |
Josh Burns Macnamara | Absent | |
Anthony Byrne Holt | Absent | |
Jim Chalmers Rankin | Absent | |
Nick Champion Spence | Absent | |
Sharon Claydon Newcastle | Absent | |
Libby Coker Corangamite | Absent | |
Pat Conroy Shortland | Absent | |
Milton Dick Oxley | Absent | |
Mark Dreyfus Isaacs | Absent | |
Steve Georganas Adelaide | Absent | |
Patrick Gorman Perth | Absent | |
Luke Gosling Solomon | Absent | |
Julian Hill Bruce | Absent | |
Ed Husic Chifley | Absent | |
Ged Kearney Cooper | Absent | |
Matt Keogh Burt | Absent | |
Peter Khalil Wills | Absent | |
Catherine King Ballarat | Absent | |
Madeleine King Brand | Absent | |
Richard Marles Corio | Absent | |
Rob Mitchell McEwen | Absent | |
Daniel Mulino Fraser | Absent | |
Shayne Neumann Blair | Absent | |
Clare O'Neil Hotham | Absent | |
Alicia Payne Canberra | Absent | |
Graham Perrett Moreton | Absent | |
Michelle Rowland Greenway | Absent | |
Joanne Ryan Lalor | Absent | |
Bill Shorten Maribyrnong | Absent | |
David Smith Bean | Absent | |
Matt Thistlethwaite Kingsford Smith | Absent | |
Kate Thwaites Jagajaga | Absent | |
Maria Vamvakinou Calwell | Absent | |
Anika Wells Lilley | Absent | |
Tony Zappia Makin | Absent | |
Rebekha Sharkie Mayo Centre Alliance | Absent | |
Mark Coulton Parkes Deputy Speaker | Yes | |
Helen Haines Indi Independent | Yes | |
Zali Steggall Warringah Independent | Absent | |
Andrew Wilkie Clark Independent | Absent | |
Bob Katter Kennedy Katter's Australian Party | Absent | |
Liberal National Party (50% turnout) | 2 Yes – 0 No | |
Angie Bell Moncrieff | Yes | |
Julian Simmonds Ryan | Yes | |
Phillip Thompson Herbert | Absent | |
Terry Young Longman | Absent | |
Liberal Party (54% turnout) | 30 Yes – 0 No | |
Katie Allen Higgins | Yes | |
Karen Andrews McPherson | Yes | |
Bridget Archer Bass | Yes | |
Peter Dutton Dickson | Yes | |
Jason Falinski Mackellar | Yes | |
Paul Fletcher Bradfield | Yes | |
Nicolle Flint Boothby | Yes | |
Josh Frydenberg Kooyong | Yes | |
Celia Hammond Curtin | Yes | |
Alex Hawke Mitchell | Yes | |
Greg Hunt Flinders | Yes | |
Julian Leeser Berowra | Yes | |
Sussan Ley Farrer | Yes | |
Melissa McIntosh Lindsay | Yes | |
Scott Morrison Cook | Yes | |
Tony Pasin Barker | Yes | |
Christian Porter Pearce | Yes | |
Melissa Price Durack | Yes | |
Rowan Ramsey Grey | Yes | |
Stuart Robert Fadden | Yes | |
Michael Sukkar Deakin | Yes | |
Angus Taylor Hume | Yes | |
Dan Tehan Wannon | Yes | |
Alan Tudge Aston | Yes | |
Bert Van Manen Forde | Yes | |
Ross Vasta Bonner | Yes | |
Andrew Wallace Fisher | Yes | |
Lucy Wicks Robertson | Yes | |
Ken Wyatt Hasluck | Yes | |
Trent Zimmerman North Sydney | Yes | |
John Alexander Bennelong | Absent | |
Kevin Andrews Menzies | Absent | |
Russell Broadbent Monash | Absent | |
Scott Buchholz Wright | Absent | |
David Coleman Banks | Absent | |
Vince Connelly Stirling | Absent | |
Warren Entsch Leichhardt | Absent | |
Trevor Evans Brisbane | Absent | |
Ian Goodenough Moore | Absent | |
Andrew Hastie Canning | Absent | |
Luke Howarth Petrie | Absent | |
Steve Irons Swan | Absent | |
Craig Kelly Hughes | Absent | |
Andrew Laming Bowman | Absent | |
Gladys Liu Chisholm | Absent | |
Nola Marino Forrest | Absent | |
Fiona Martin Reid | Absent | |
John McVeigh Groom | Absent | |
Ben Morton Tangney | Absent | |
Ted O'Brien Fairfax | Absent | |
Gavin Pearce Braddon | Absent | |
Dave Sharma Wentworth | Absent | |
James Stevens Sturt | Absent | |
Rick Wilson O'Connor | Absent | |
Tim Wilson Goldstein | Absent | |
Jason Wood La Trobe | Absent | |
National Party (53% turnout) | 8 Yes – 0 No | |
Andrew Gee Calare | Yes | |
David Gillespie Lyne | Yes | |
Barnaby Joyce New England | Yes | |
David Littleproud Maranoa | Yes | |
Michael McCormack Riverina | Yes | |
Ken O'Dowd Flynn | Yes | |
Keith Pitt Hinkler | Yes | |
Anne Webster Mallee | Yes | |
Darren Chester Gippsland | Absent | |
George Christensen Dawson | Absent | |
Pat Conaghan Cowper | Absent | |
Damian Drum Nicholls | Absent | |
Kevin Hogan Page | Absent | |
Michelle Landry Capricornia | Absent | |
Llew O'Brien Wide Bay | Absent | |
Tony Smith Casey Speaker | Absent | |
Totals (49% turnout) | 42 Yes – 32 No |
Turnout is the percentage of members eligible to vote that did vote.