edited
7th Nov 2014
Constitution Alteration (Local Government) 2013 - Third Reading - Pass the bill
Jill Hall voted Yes
Russell Broadbent voted Yes
Passed by a large majority
2 rebellions 89% attendance
Jill Hall and Russell Broadbent have voted the same way 1% of the time
Jill Hall
Former Australian Labor Party Representative for Shortland October 1998 – May 2016
Russell Broadbent
Independent Representative for Monash since November 2023
Between February 2006 (when our voting records begin) and May 2016 Jill Hall and Russell Broadbent have voted in the same division 1448 times.
In divisions they have voted differently 1435 times. They have only voted the same 13 times.
How do their votes on policies compare?
Policies are groups of votes related to an issue. We only show policies where we have enough information on both people.
Always voted the same way on
Voted a mixture of the same and differently on
Always voted differently on
- A carbon price
- A minerals resource rent tax
- A plebiscite on the carbon pricing mechanism
- An Australian Building and Construction Commission (ABCC)
- An emissions reduction fund
- Carbon farming
- Charging postgraduate research students fees
- Compensating victims of overseas terrorism since the September 11 attack
- Decreasing availability of welfare payments
- Decreasing the private health insurance rebate
- Deregulating undergraduate university fees
- Ending illegal logging
- Government administered paid parental leave
- Implementing refugee and protection conventions
- Increasing Aboriginal land rights
- Increasing consumer protections
- Increasing eligibility requirements for Australian citizenship
- Increasing fishing restrictions
- Increasing funding for road infrastructure
- Increasing indexation of HECS-HELP debts
- Increasing investment in renewable energy
- Increasing marine conservation
- Increasing or removing the Government debt limit
- Increasing political transparency
- Increasing protection of Australia's fresh water
- Increasing restrictions on gambling
- Increasing scrutiny of asylum seeker management
- Increasing scrutiny of unions
- Increasing the age pension
- Increasing the diversity of media ownership
- Increasing the price of subsidised medicine
- Increasing trade unions' powers in the workplace
- Increasing transparency of big business by making information public
- Letting all MPs or Senators speak in Parliament (procedural)
- Letting environmental groups challenge the legality of certain government decisions
- Making more water from Murray-Darling Basin available to use
- Privatising government-owned assets
- Re-approving/ re-registering agvet chemicals
- Removing children from immigration detention
- Restricting donations to political parties
- Restricting foreign ownership
- Same-sex marriage equality
- Senate electoral reform
- Speeding things along in Parliament (procedural)
- Stopping tax avoidance or aggressive tax minimisation
- Suspending the rules to allow a vote to happen (procedural)
- Temporary protection visas
- The Australian Renewable Energy Agency (ARENA)
- The Carbon Pollution Reduction Scheme
- The Intervention in the Northern Territory
- Tighter means testing of family payments
- Turning back asylum boats when possible
- Unconventional gas mining
- Voluntary student union fees
Divisions in which they voted the same
In divisions they have voted differently 1435 times. They have only voted the same 13 times.
-
-
Motions — Murray-Darling Basin Plan; Disallowance
Jill Hall voted No
Russell Broadbent voted No
Not passed by a large majority
2 rebellions 67% attendance
-
edited 7th Oct 2014
Mental Health - Recommital of Vote - Greens amendment
Jill Hall voted Yes
Russell Broadbent voted Yes
Passed by a large majority
1 rebellion 85% attendance
-
edited 7th Oct 2014
Wheat Export Marketing Bill 2008 - Third Reading - Read a third time
Jill Hall voted Yes
Russell Broadbent voted Yes
Passed by a large majority
2 rebellions 83% attendance
-
edited 7th Oct 2014
Wheat Export Marketing Bill 2008 - Second Reading - Read a second time
Jill Hall voted Yes
Russell Broadbent voted Yes
Passed by a large majority
No rebellions 91% attendance
-
edited 7th Oct 2014
Prohibition of Human Cloning for Reproduction and the Regulation of Human Embryo Research Amendment Bill 2006 - Consideration in Detail - Offence of using precursor cells
Jill Hall voted No in this free vote
Russell Broadbent voted No in this free vote
Not passed by a small majority
No rebellions 86% attendance
-
edited 7th Oct 2014
Prohibition of Human Cloning for Reproduction and the Regulation of Human Embryo Research Amendment Bill 2006 — Consideration in Detail — Offence of using precursor cells
Jill Hall voted No in this free vote
Russell Broadbent voted No in this free vote
Not passed by a small majority
No rebellions 86% attendance
-
edited 7th Oct 2014
Prohibition of Human Cloning for Reproduction and the Regulation of Human Embryo Research Amendment Bill 2006 - Second Reading - Read a second time
Jill Hall voted Yes in this free vote
Russell Broadbent voted Yes in this free vote
Passed by a small majority
No rebellions 96% attendance
-
edited 7th Oct 2014
Migration Amendment (Designated Unauthorised Arrivals) Bill 2006 — Third Reading — Read a third time
Jill Hall voted No
Russell Broadbent voted No, rebelling against the Liberal Party
Passed by a small majority
3 rebellions 94% attendance
-
edited 7th Oct 2014
Migration Amendment (Designated Unauthorised Arrivals) Bill 2006 - Third Reading - Read a third time
Jill Hall voted No
Russell Broadbent voted No, rebelling against the Liberal Party
Passed by a small majority
3 rebellions 94% attendance
-
edited 7th Oct 2014
Migration Amendment (Designated Unauthorised Arrivals) Bill 2006 - Second Reading - Read a second time
Jill Hall voted No
Russell Broadbent voted No, rebelling against the Liberal Party
Passed by a small majority
3 rebellions 93% attendance
-
edited 7th Oct 2014
Therapeutic Goods Amendment (Repeal of Ministerial Responsibility for Approval of Ru486) Bill 2005 - Consideration in Detail - Amend the current process
Jill Hall voted No in this free vote
Russell Broadbent voted No in this free vote
Not passed by a small majority
No rebellions 97% attendance
-
edited 7th Oct 2014
Therapeutic Goods Amendment (Repeal of Ministerial Responsibility for Approval of Ru486) Bill 2005 - Second Reading - Bill unacceptable
Jill Hall voted No in this free vote
Russell Broadbent voted No in this free vote
Not passed by a small majority
No rebellions 97% attendance