Division Description Changes — Motions — Wind Farms — 8th Feb 2012

All changes made to the description and title of this division.

View division | Edit description

Change	Division
senate vote 2012-02-08#2 Edited by system on 2014-10-07 16:20:44	Title Description The majority voted in favour of an [http://www.openaustralia.org/senate/?gid=2012-02-08.136.1 amendment] introduced by Senator [http://publicwhip-test.openaustraliafoundation.org.au/mp.php?mpn=Simon_Birmingham&mpc=Senate&house=senate Simon Birmingham]. The [http://www.openaustralia.org/senate/?gid=2012-02-08.135.2 original motion] that Senator Birmingham wanted to amend was introduced by Senator [http://publicwhip-test.openaustraliafoundation.org.au/mp.php?mpn=John_Madigan&mpc=Senate&house=senate John Madigan]. It was: "''That the Senate—'' ''(a) notes that on 23 June 2011 the [http://www.aph.gov.au/Parliamentary_Business/Committees/Senate/Community_Affairs Community Affairs References Committee] tabled its final report,(Read the full report [http://aefweb.info/data/Senate%20Report%20on%20Wind%20Farms%20230611.pdf here] (2.7 MB). Read the Government's response to the report's recommendations [http://www.health.gov.au/internet/main/publishing.nsf/Content/36DB83157C4BE82FCA257BF0001B7544/$File/Wind%20Farm%20Response.pdf here] (344 KB). More information about the health concerns related to wind farms is available [http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wind_farms#Human_health here].) Social and economic impact of rural wind farms containing seven recommendations, including recommendations calling for studies on the effects of [http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wind_farm wind farms] on human health; and'' ~~''(b) calls on the Government to:''~~ ~~''(i) immediately act on the committee's recommendations in the report, and''~~ ''(ii) support a [http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Moratorium_%28law%29 moratorium] on the construction of further [http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wind_turbines wind turbines] until the recommendations have been satisfactorily addressed.''" ~~Senator Birmingham's amendment to this motion was:~~ "''That the Senate—'' ~~''Omit subparagraph (b)(ii), so that paragraph (b) now reads:''~~ ~~''(b) calls on the Government to immediately act on the committee's recommendations in the report.''"~~ ~~References~~ The majority voted in favour of an [amendment](http://www.openaustralia.org/senate/?gid=2012-02-08.136.1) introduced by Senator [Simon Birmingham](http://publicwhip-rails.openaustraliafoundation.org.au/mp.php?mpn=Simon_Birmingham&mpc=Senate&house=senate). The [original motion](http://www.openaustralia.org/senate/?gid=2012-02-08.135.2) that Senator Birmingham wanted to amend was introduced by Senator [John Madigan](http://publicwhip-rails.openaustraliafoundation.org.au/mp.php?mpn=John_Madigan&mpc=Senate&house=senate). It was: "_That the Senate—_ _(a) notes that on 23 June 2011 the [Community Affairs References Committee](http://www.aph.gov.au/Parliamentary_Business/Committees/Senate/Community_Affairs) tabled its final report,(Read the full report [here](http://aefweb.info/data/Senate%20Report%20on%20Wind%20Farms%20230611.pdf) (2.7 MB). Read the Government's response to the report's recommendations [here](http://www.health.gov.au/internet/main/publishing.nsf/Content/36DB83157C4BE82FCA257BF0001B7544/$File/Wind%20Farm%20Response.pdf) (344 KB). More information about the health concerns related to wind farms is available [here](http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wind_farms#Human_health).) Social and economic impact of rural wind farms containing seven recommendations, including recommendations calling for studies on the effects of [wind farms](http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wind_farm) on human health; and_ _(b) calls on the Government to:_ _(i) immediately act on the committee's recommendations in the report, and_ _(ii) support a [moratorium](http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Moratorium_%28law%29) on the construction of further [wind turbines](http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wind_turbines) until the recommendations have been satisfactorily addressed._" Senator Birmingham's amendment to this motion was: "_That the Senate—_ _Omit subparagraph (b)(ii), so that paragraph (b) now reads:_ _(b) calls on the Government to immediately act on the committee's recommendations in the report._" References
senate vote 2012-02-08#2 Edited by system on 2014-10-07 16:16:49	Title Description The majority voted in favour of an [http://www.openaustralia.org/senate/?gid=2012-02-08.136.1 amendment] introduced by Senator [http://publicwhip-test.openaustraliafoundation.org.au/mp.php?mpn=Simon_Birmingham&mpc=Senate&house=senate Simon Birmingham]. The [http://www.openaustralia.org/senate/?gid=2012-02-08.135.2 original motion] that Senator Birmingham wanted to amend was introduced by Senator [http://publicwhip-test.openaustraliafoundation.org.au/mp.php?mpn=John_Madigan&mpc=Senate&house=senate John Madigan]. It was: "''That the Senate—'' ''(a) notes that on 23 June 2011 the [http://www.aph.gov.au/Parliamentary_Business/Committees/Senate/Community_Affairs Community Affairs References Committee] tabled its final report,[1] Social and economic impact of rural wind farms containing seven recommendations, including recommendations calling for studies on the effects of [http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wind_farm wind farms] on human health; and'' ''(a) notes that on 23 June 2011 the [http://www.aph.gov.au/Parliamentary_Business/Committees/Senate/Community_Affairs Community Affairs References Committee] tabled its final report,(Read the full report [http://aefweb.info/data/Senate%20Report%20on%20Wind%20Farms%20230611.pdf here] (2.7 MB). Read the Government's response to the report's recommendations [http://www.health.gov.au/internet/main/publishing.nsf/Content/36DB83157C4BE82FCA257BF0001B7544/$File/Wind%20Farm%20Response.pdf here] (344 KB). More information about the health concerns related to wind farms is available [http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wind_farms#Human_health here].) Social and economic impact of rural wind farms containing seven recommendations, including recommendations calling for studies on the effects of [http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wind_farm wind farms] on human health; and'' ''(b) calls on the Government to:'' ''(i) immediately act on the committee's recommendations in the report, and'' ''(ii) support a [http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Moratorium_%28law%29 moratorium] on the construction of further [http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wind_turbines wind turbines] until the recommendations have been satisfactorily addressed.''" Senator Birmingham's amendment to this motion was: "''That the Senate—'' ''Omit subparagraph (b)(ii), so that paragraph (b) now reads:'' ''(b) calls on the Government to immediately act on the committee's recommendations in the report.''" References * [1] Read the full report [http://aefweb.info/data/Senate%20Report%20on%20Wind%20Farms%20230611.pdf here] (2.7 MB). Read the Government's response to the report's recommendations [http://www.health.gov.au/internet/main/publishing.nsf/Content/36DB83157C4BE82FCA257BF0001B7544/$File/Wind%20Farm%20Response.pdf here] (344 KB). More information about the health concerns related to wind farms is available [http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wind_farms#Human_health here].
senate vote 2012-02-08#2 Edited by mackay staff on 2014-04-15 16:19:40	Title Description The majority voted in favour of an [http://www.openaustralia.org/senate/?gid=2012-02-08.136.1 amendment] introduced by Senator [http://publicwhip-test.openaustraliafoundation.org.au/mp.php?mpn=Simon_Birmingham&mpc=Senate&house=senate Simon Birmingham]. The [http://www.openaustralia.org/senate/?gid=2012-02-08.135.2 original motion] that Senator Birmingham wanted to amend was introduced by Senator [http://publicwhip-test.openaustraliafoundation.org.au/mp.php?mpn=John_Madigan&mpc=Senate&house=senate John Madigan]. It was: "''That the Senate—'' ''(a) notes that on 23 June 2011 the [http://www.aph.gov.au/Parliamentary_Business/Committees/Senate/Community_Affairs Community Affairs References Committee] tabled its final report,[1] Social and economic impact of rural wind farms containing seven recommendations, including recommendations calling for studies on the effects of wind farms on human health; and'' ''(a) notes that on 23 June 2011 the [http://www.aph.gov.au/Parliamentary_Business/Committees/Senate/Community_Affairs Community Affairs References Committee] tabled its final report,[1] Social and economic impact of rural wind farms containing seven recommendations, including recommendations calling for studies on the effects of [http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wind_farm wind farms] on human health; and'' ''(b) calls on the Government to:'' ''(i) immediately act on the committee's recommendations in the report, and'' ~~''(ii) support a [http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Moratorium_%28law%29 moratorium] on the construction of further wind turbines until the recommendations have been satisfactorily addressed.''"~~ ''(ii) support a [http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Moratorium_%28law%29 moratorium] on the construction of further [http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wind_turbines wind turbines] until the recommendations have been satisfactorily addressed.''" Senator Birmingham's amendment to this motion was: "''That the Senate—'' ''Omit subparagraph (b)(ii), so that paragraph (b) now reads:'' ''(b) calls on the Government to immediately act on the committee's recommendations in the report.''" References * [1] Read the full report [http://aefweb.info/data/Senate%20Report%20on%20Wind%20Farms%20230611.pdf here] (2.7 MB). Read the Government's response to the report's recommendations [http://www.health.gov.au/internet/main/publishing.nsf/Content/36DB83157C4BE82FCA257BF0001B7544/$File/Wind%20Farm%20Response.pdf here] (344 KB). More information about the health concerns related to wind farms is available [http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wind_farms#Human_health here].
senate vote 2012-02-08#2 Edited by mackay staff on 2014-04-15 16:16:41	Title Description The majority voted in favour of an [http://www.openaustralia.org/senate/?gid=2012-02-08.136.1 amendment] introduced by Senator [http://publicwhip-test.openaustraliafoundation.org.au/mp.php?mpn=Simon_Birmingham&mpc=Senate&house=senate Simon Birmingham]. The [http://www.openaustralia.org/senate/?gid=2012-02-08.135.2 original motion] that Senator Birmingham wanted to amend was introduced by Senator [http://publicwhip-test.openaustraliafoundation.org.au/mp.php?mpn=John_Madigan&mpc=Senate&house=senate John Madigan]. It was: "''That the Senate—'' ''(a) notes that on 23 June 2011 the [http://www.aph.gov.au/Parliamentary_Business/Committees/Senate/Community_Affairs Community Affairs References Committee] tabled its final report, Social and economic impact of rural wind farms containing seven recommendations, including recommendations calling for studies on the effects of wind farms on human health; and''[1] ''(a) notes that on 23 June 2011 the [http://www.aph.gov.au/Parliamentary_Business/Committees/Senate/Community_Affairs Community Affairs References Committee] tabled its final report,[1] Social and economic impact of rural wind farms containing seven recommendations, including recommendations calling for studies on the effects of wind farms on human health; and'' ''(b) calls on the Government to:'' ''(i) immediately act on the committee's recommendations in the report, and'' ''(ii) support a [http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Moratorium_%28law%29 moratorium] on the construction of further wind turbines until the recommendations have been satisfactorily addressed.''" Senator Birmingham's amendment to this motion was: "''That the Senate—'' ''Omit subparagraph (b)(ii), so that paragraph (b) now reads:'' ''(b) calls on the Government to immediately act on the committee's recommendations in the report.''" References * [1] Read the full report [http://aefweb.info/data/Senate%20Report%20on%20Wind%20Farms%20230611.pdf here] (2.7 MB). Read the Government's response to the report's recommendations [http://www.health.gov.au/internet/main/publishing.nsf/Content/36DB83157C4BE82FCA257BF0001B7544/$File/Wind%20Farm%20Response.pdf here] (344 KB). More information about the health concerns related to wind farms is available [http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wind_farms#Human_health here].
senate vote 2012-02-08#2 Edited by mackay staff on 2014-04-15 16:15:40	Title ~~Motions - Wind Farms - Act on the Community Affairs References Committee's recommentations~~ Motions - Wind Farms - Act on the Community Affairs References Committee's recommendations Description The majority voted in favour of an [http://www.openaustralia.org/senate/?gid=2012-02-08.136.1 amendment] introduced by Senator [http://publicwhip-test.openaustraliafoundation.org.au/mp.php?mpn=Simon_Birmingham&mpc=Senate&house=senate Simon Birmingham]. The [http://www.openaustralia.org/senate/?gid=2012-02-08.135.2 original motion] that Senator Birmingham wanted to amend was introduced by Senator [http://publicwhip-test.openaustraliafoundation.org.au/mp.php?mpn=John_Madigan&mpc=Senate&house=senate John Madigan]. It was: "''That the Senate—'' ''(a) notes that on 23 June 2011 the [http://www.aph.gov.au/Parliamentary_Business/Committees/Senate/Community_Affairs Community Affairs References Committee] tabled its final report, Social and economic impact of rural wind farms containing seven recommendations, including recommendations calling for studies on the effects of wind farms on human health; and''[1] ''(b) calls on the Government to:'' ''(i) immediately act on the committee's recommendations in the report, and'' ''(ii) support a [http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Moratorium_%28law%29 moratorium] on the construction of further wind turbines until the recommendations have been satisfactorily addressed.''" Senator Birmingham's amendment to this motion was: "''That the Senate—'' ''Omit subparagraph (b)(ii), so that paragraph (b) now reads:'' ''(b) calls on the Government to immediately act on the committee's recommendations in the report.''" References * [1] Read the full report [http://aefweb.info/data/Senate%20Report%20on%20Wind%20Farms%20230611.pdf here] (2.7 MB). Read the Government's response to the report's recommendations [http://www.health.gov.au/internet/main/publishing.nsf/Content/36DB83157C4BE82FCA257BF0001B7544/$File/Wind%20Farm%20Response.pdf here] (344 KB). More information about the health concerns related to wind farms is available [http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wind_farms#Human_health here].
senate vote 2012-02-08#2 Edited by mackay staff on 2014-04-15 16:14:25	Title ~~Motions - Wind Farms - Act on Community Affairs References Committee's recommentations~~ Motions - Wind Farms - Act on the Community Affairs References Committee's recommentations Description The majority voted in favour of an [http://www.openaustralia.org/senate/?gid=2012-02-08.136.1 amendment] introduced by Senator [http://publicwhip-test.openaustraliafoundation.org.au/mp.php?mpn=Simon_Birmingham&mpc=Senate&house=senate Simon Birmingham]. The [http://www.openaustralia.org/senate/?gid=2012-02-08.135.2 original motion] that Senator Birmingham wanted to amend was introduced by Senator [http://publicwhip-test.openaustraliafoundation.org.au/mp.php?mpn=John_Madigan&mpc=Senate&house=senate John Madigan]. It was: "''That the Senate—'' ''(a) notes that on 23 June 2011 the [http://www.aph.gov.au/Parliamentary_Business/Committees/Senate/Community_Affairs Community Affairs References Committee] tabled its final report, Social and economic impact of rural wind farms containing seven recommendations, including recommendations calling for studies on the effects of wind farms on human health; and''[1] ''(b) calls on the Government to:'' ''(i) immediately act on the committee's recommendations in the report, and'' ''(ii) support a [http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Moratorium_%28law%29 moratorium] on the construction of further wind turbines until the recommendations have been satisfactorily addressed.''" Senator Birmingham's amendment to this motion was: "''That the Senate—'' ''Omit subparagraph (b)(ii), so that paragraph (b) now reads:'' ''(b) calls on the Government to immediately act on the committee's recommendations in the report.''" References * [1] Read the full report [http://aefweb.info/data/Senate%20Report%20on%20Wind%20Farms%20230611.pdf here] (2.7 MB). Read the Government's response to the report's recommendations [http://www.health.gov.au/internet/main/publishing.nsf/Content/36DB83157C4BE82FCA257BF0001B7544/$File/Wind%20Farm%20Response.pdf here] (344 KB). More information about the health concerns related to wind farms is available [http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wind_farms#Human_health here]. * [1] Read the full report [http://aefweb.info/data/Senate%20Report%20on%20Wind%20Farms%20230611.pdf here] (2.7 MB). Read the Government's response to the report's recommendations [http://www.health.gov.au/internet/main/publishing.nsf/Content/36DB83157C4BE82FCA257BF0001B7544/$File/Wind%20Farm%20Response.pdf here] (344 KB). More information about the health concerns related to wind farms is available [http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wind_farms#Human_health here].
senate vote 2012-02-08#2 Edited by mackay staff on 2014-04-15 16:13:59	Title ~~Motions — Wind Farms~~ Motions - Wind Farms - Act on Community Affairs References Committee's recommentations Description ~~<p class="speaker">John Madigan</p>~~ ~~<p>I, and also on behalf of Senator Xenophon, move:</p>~~ <p class="italic">That the Senate—</p> <p class="italic">  (a)   notes that on 23 June 2011 the Community Affairs References Committee tabled its final report, <i>Social and economic impact of rural wind farms</i> containing seven recommendations, including recommendations calling for studies on the effects of wind farms on human health; and</p> ~~<p class="italic">  (b)   calls on the Government to:</p>~~ ~~<p class="italic">     (i)   immediately act on the committee's recommendations in the report, and</p>~~ <p class="italic">     (ii)   support a moratorium on the construction of further wind turbines until the recommendations have been satisfactorily addressed.</p> <p class="speaker">Simon Birmingham</p> ~~<p>I seek leave to move an amendment to the motion.</p>~~ ~~<p>Leave granted.</p>~~ ~~<p>I move:</p>~~ <p class="italic">That the Senate—</p> ~~<p class="italic">Omit subparagraph (b)(ii), so that paragraph (b) now reads:</p>~~ <p class="italic">(b) calls on the Government to immediately act on the committee's recommendations in the report.</p> ~~<p class="speaker">Rachel Siewert</p>~~ <p>I would like to be really clear because there has been some confusion around this motion. Are we amending the motion that was circulated that was actually in the <i>Notice Paper</i>? It is not the one that Senator Madigan was subsequently talking to people about?</p> ~~<p class="speaker">Stephen Parry</p>~~ <p>We are dealing with the motion that would appear on the <i>Notice Paper </i>as No. 616. There is an amendment moved by Senator Birmingham to that notice. We cannot deal with a motion that we do not have before us, so it must be the one that is in the <i>Notice Paper</i>.</p> ~~<p class="speaker">Rachel Siewert</p>~~ <p>So all we are doing now through this motion is supporting the implementation of the recommendations of the Community Affairs References Committee? I want to be really clear about what we are voting on.</p> ~~<p class="speaker">Simon Birmingham</p>~~ <p>That is correct. This would delete and omit part (b)(ii) of motion No. 616 in the <i>Notice Paper</i>. That would leave the remaining part calling on the government to immediately act on the committee's recommendations in the report relating to wind farms.</p> ~~<p class="speaker">John Madigan</p>~~ ~~<p>Mr Deputy President, I seek leave to make a brief statement.</p>~~ ~~<p class="speaker">Stephen Parry</p>~~ ~~<p>Leave is granted for two minutes.</p>~~ ~~<p class="speaker">John Madigan</p>~~ <p>The Senate inquiry into the social and economic impact of rural wind farms received more than 100,000 submissions and made only seven recommendations. It is now 7½ months later and not one of these recommendations has been implemented. I have been holding wind farm forums across the country and have been overwhelmed by the stories of families living close to turbines. I am calling for the government to act on the recommendations given by its own inquiry chaired by Senator Siewert. The motion also calls for a moratorium on the construction of any new wind turbines. This call is identical to the moratoriums that other parties have called for when the adverse health effects of new technologies have been raised. If there is no moratorium, there is no incentive to act. I am not a scientist. Perhaps the severe debilitating effects of wind farms can be solved by a simple engineering solution. I do not know. We need to stop the construction of any further wind turbines until we can study any problems and implement the recommendations that the Senate inquiry itself has made. Personal and community health need to be at the top of our concerns as elected representatives. Protecting and serving people is our prime reason for being in parliament.</p> ~~<p class="speaker">Simon Birmingham</p>~~ ~~<p>I seek leave to make a very short statement.</p>~~ ~~<p class="speaker">Stephen Parry</p>~~ ~~<p>Leave is granted for two minutes.</p>~~ <p class="speaker">Simon Birmingham</p> <p>On behalf of the coalition—and I have explained what this amendment seeks to do—I say that we are very sympathetic to the issues that Senator Madigan has raised through this motion and that we do understand his concerns. Indeed, coalition senators—in particular, Senator Adams—have championed a number of these issues and concerns. We share Senator Madigan's concerns, and those of many in the community, that the government has not acted swiftly enough to implement the recommendations of this report. We hope that the Senate will pass the motion, brought forward by Senator Madigan in the amended terms, to try to increase the pressure on the government to do so. However, we do recognise that significant investments which have already been made and are in play would be impacted by a moratorium, and that would create a degree of business uncertainty. Unfortunately, that is why we find ourselves moving this amendment calling for the omission of a section of the motion.</p> ~~<p class="speaker">Nick Xenophon</p>~~ ~~<p>I seek leave to make a brief statement.</p>~~ ~~<p class="speaker">Stephen Parry</p>~~ ~~<p>Leave is granted for two minutes.</p>~~ ~~<p class="speaker">Nick Xenophon</p>~~ <p>I support the remarks of Senator Madigan. I make it clear that I think wind farms are an important part of the renewable energy mix. But there are genuine community concerns, as witnessed by the Senate inquiry into this. There were seven unanimous recommendations which seem to be reasonable and measured. They take a precautionary approach to the concerns of communities about wind farms and to addressing these concerns by ensuring that the health effects and other matters are dealt with. I think they are quite reasonable recommendations. I think it makes sense that, if you think that the government should act on these recommendations— such as the recommendation that the NHMRC be involved in monitoring the health effects—then it is not unreasonable that there be a moratorium until the recommendations are acted on. The moratorium would not necessarily have to last very long, but it would be an incentive to ensure that the recommendations are acted upon and community concerns comprehensively dealt with once and for all. That is why I think it is important, given the context of the inquiry, for the moratorium to be supported as well as the recommendations.</p> ~~<p class="speaker">John Hogg</p>~~ ~~<p>The question is that the amendment moved by Senator Birmingham be agreed to.</p>~~ ~~<p>The question now is that the motion, as amended, be agreed to.</p>~~ ~~<p>Question agreed to.</p>~~ The majority voted in favour of an [http://www.openaustralia.org/senate/?gid=2012-02-08.136.1 amendment] introduced by Senator [http://publicwhip-test.openaustraliafoundation.org.au/mp.php?mpn=Simon_Birmingham&mpc=Senate&house=senate Simon Birmingham]. The [http://www.openaustralia.org/senate/?gid=2012-02-08.135.2 original motion] that Senator Birmingham wanted to amend was introduced by Senator [http://publicwhip-test.openaustraliafoundation.org.au/mp.php?mpn=John_Madigan&mpc=Senate&house=senate John Madigan]. It was: "''That the Senate—'' ''(a) notes that on 23 June 2011 the [http://www.aph.gov.au/Parliamentary_Business/Committees/Senate/Community_Affairs Community Affairs References Committee] tabled its final report, Social and economic impact of rural wind farms containing seven recommendations, including recommendations calling for studies on the effects of wind farms on human health; and''[1] ''(b) calls on the Government to:'' ''(i) immediately act on the committee's recommendations in the report, and'' ''(ii) support a [http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Moratorium_%28law%29 moratorium] on the construction of further wind turbines until the recommendations have been satisfactorily addressed.''" Senator Birmingham's amendment to this motion was: "''That the Senate—'' ''Omit subparagraph (b)(ii), so that paragraph (b) now reads:'' ''(b) calls on the Government to immediately act on the committee's recommendations in the report.''" References * [1] Read the full report [http://aefweb.info/data/Senate%20Report%20on%20Wind%20Farms%20230611.pdf here] (2.7 MB). Read the Government's response to the report's recommendations [http://www.health.gov.au/internet/main/publishing.nsf/Content/36DB83157C4BE82FCA257BF0001B7544/$File/Wind%20Farm%20Response.pdf here] (344 KB). More information about the health concerns related to wind farms is available [http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wind_farms#Human_health here].

Change

Division

senate vote 2012-02-08#2

Edited by system

on 2014-10-07 16:20:44

Title

Description

The majority voted in favour of an [http://www.openaustralia.org/senate/?gid=2012-02-08.136.1 amendment] introduced by Senator [http://publicwhip-test.openaustraliafoundation.org.au/mp.php?mpn=Simon_Birmingham&mpc=Senate&house=senate Simon Birmingham].
The [http://www.openaustralia.org/senate/?gid=2012-02-08.135.2 original motion] that Senator Birmingham wanted to amend was introduced by Senator [http://publicwhip-test.openaustraliafoundation.org.au/mp.php?mpn=John_Madigan&mpc=Senate&house=senate John Madigan]. It was:
"''That the Senate—''
''(a) notes that on 23 June 2011 the [http://www.aph.gov.au/Parliamentary_Business/Committees/Senate/Community_Affairs Community Affairs References Committee] tabled its final report,(Read the full report [http://aefweb.info/data/Senate%20Report%20on%20Wind%20Farms%20230611.pdf here] (2.7 MB). Read the Government's response to the report's recommendations [http://www.health.gov.au/internet/main/publishing.nsf/Content/36DB83157C4BE82FCA257BF0001B7544/$File/Wind%20Farm%20Response.pdf here] (344 KB). More information about the health concerns related to wind farms is available [http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wind_farms#Human_health here].) Social and economic impact of rural wind farms containing seven recommendations, including recommendations calling for studies on the effects of [http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wind_farm wind farms] on human health; and''
~~''(b) calls on the Government to:''~~
~~''(i) immediately act on the committee's recommendations in the report, and''~~
''(ii) support a [http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Moratorium_%28law%29 moratorium] on the construction of further [http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wind_turbines wind turbines] until the recommendations have been satisfactorily addressed.''"
~~Senator Birmingham's amendment to this motion was:~~
"''That the Senate—''
~~''Omit subparagraph (b)(ii), so that paragraph (b) now reads:''~~
~~''(b) calls on the Government to immediately act on the committee's recommendations in the report.''"~~
~~References~~
The majority voted in favour of an [amendment](http://www.openaustralia.org/senate/?gid=2012-02-08.136.1) introduced by Senator [Simon Birmingham](http://publicwhip-rails.openaustraliafoundation.org.au/mp.php?mpn=Simon_Birmingham&mpc=Senate&house=senate).
The [original motion](http://www.openaustralia.org/senate/?gid=2012-02-08.135.2) that Senator Birmingham wanted to amend was introduced by Senator [John Madigan](http://publicwhip-rails.openaustraliafoundation.org.au/mp.php?mpn=John_Madigan&mpc=Senate&house=senate). It was:
"_That the Senate—_
_(a) notes that on 23 June 2011 the [Community Affairs References Committee](http://www.aph.gov.au/Parliamentary_Business/Committees/Senate/Community_Affairs) tabled its final report,(Read the full report [here](http://aefweb.info/data/Senate%20Report%20on%20Wind%20Farms%20230611.pdf) (2.7 MB). Read the Government's response to the report's recommendations [here](http://www.health.gov.au/internet/main/publishing.nsf/Content/36DB83157C4BE82FCA257BF0001B7544/$File/Wind%20Farm%20Response.pdf) (344 KB). More information about the health concerns related to wind farms is available [here](http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wind_farms#Human_health).) Social and economic impact of rural wind farms containing seven recommendations, including recommendations calling for studies on the effects of [wind farms](http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wind_farm) on human health; and_
_(b) calls on the Government to:_
_(i) immediately act on the committee's recommendations in the report, and_
_(ii) support a [moratorium](http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Moratorium_%28law%29) on the construction of further [wind turbines](http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wind_turbines) until the recommendations have been satisfactorily addressed._"
Senator Birmingham's amendment to this motion was:
"_That the Senate—_
_Omit subparagraph (b)(ii), so that paragraph (b) now reads:_
_(b) calls on the Government to immediately act on the committee's recommendations in the report._"
References

senate vote 2012-02-08#2

Edited by system

on 2014-10-07 16:16:49

Title

Description

The majority voted in favour of an [http://www.openaustralia.org/senate/?gid=2012-02-08.136.1 amendment] introduced by Senator [http://publicwhip-test.openaustraliafoundation.org.au/mp.php?mpn=Simon_Birmingham&mpc=Senate&house=senate Simon Birmingham].
The [http://www.openaustralia.org/senate/?gid=2012-02-08.135.2 original motion] that Senator Birmingham wanted to amend was introduced by Senator [http://publicwhip-test.openaustraliafoundation.org.au/mp.php?mpn=John_Madigan&mpc=Senate&house=senate John Madigan]. It was:
"''That the Senate—''
''(a) notes that on 23 June 2011 the [http://www.aph.gov.au/Parliamentary_Business/Committees/Senate/Community_Affairs Community Affairs References Committee] tabled its final report,[1] Social and economic impact of rural wind farms containing seven recommendations, including recommendations calling for studies on the effects of [http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wind_farm wind farms] on human health; and''
''(a) notes that on 23 June 2011 the [http://www.aph.gov.au/Parliamentary_Business/Committees/Senate/Community_Affairs Community Affairs References Committee] tabled its final report,(Read the full report [http://aefweb.info/data/Senate%20Report%20on%20Wind%20Farms%20230611.pdf here] (2.7 MB). Read the Government's response to the report's recommendations [http://www.health.gov.au/internet/main/publishing.nsf/Content/36DB83157C4BE82FCA257BF0001B7544/$File/Wind%20Farm%20Response.pdf here] (344 KB). More information about the health concerns related to wind farms is available [http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wind_farms#Human_health here].) Social and economic impact of rural wind farms containing seven recommendations, including recommendations calling for studies on the effects of [http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wind_farm wind farms] on human health; and''
''(b) calls on the Government to:''
''(i) immediately act on the committee's recommendations in the report, and''
''(ii) support a [http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Moratorium_%28law%29 moratorium] on the construction of further [http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wind_turbines wind turbines] until the recommendations have been satisfactorily addressed.''"
Senator Birmingham's amendment to this motion was:
"''That the Senate—''
''Omit subparagraph (b)(ii), so that paragraph (b) now reads:''
''(b) calls on the Government to immediately act on the committee's recommendations in the report.''"
References
* [1] Read the full report [http://aefweb.info/data/Senate%20Report%20on%20Wind%20Farms%20230611.pdf here] (2.7 MB). Read the Government's response to the report's recommendations [http://www.health.gov.au/internet/main/publishing.nsf/Content/36DB83157C4BE82FCA257BF0001B7544/$File/Wind%20Farm%20Response.pdf here] (344 KB). More information about the health concerns related to wind farms is available [http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wind_farms#Human_health here].

senate vote 2012-02-08#2

Edited by mackay staff

on 2014-04-15 16:19:40

Title

Description

The majority voted in favour of an [http://www.openaustralia.org/senate/?gid=2012-02-08.136.1 amendment] introduced by Senator [http://publicwhip-test.openaustraliafoundation.org.au/mp.php?mpn=Simon_Birmingham&mpc=Senate&house=senate Simon Birmingham].
The [http://www.openaustralia.org/senate/?gid=2012-02-08.135.2 original motion] that Senator Birmingham wanted to amend was introduced by Senator [http://publicwhip-test.openaustraliafoundation.org.au/mp.php?mpn=John_Madigan&mpc=Senate&house=senate John Madigan]. It was:
"''That the Senate—''
''(a) notes that on 23 June 2011 the [http://www.aph.gov.au/Parliamentary_Business/Committees/Senate/Community_Affairs Community Affairs References Committee] tabled its final report,[1] Social and economic impact of rural wind farms containing seven recommendations, including recommendations calling for studies on the effects of wind farms on human health; and''
''(a) notes that on 23 June 2011 the [http://www.aph.gov.au/Parliamentary_Business/Committees/Senate/Community_Affairs Community Affairs References Committee] tabled its final report,[1] Social and economic impact of rural wind farms containing seven recommendations, including recommendations calling for studies on the effects of [http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wind_farm wind farms] on human health; and''
''(b) calls on the Government to:''
''(i) immediately act on the committee's recommendations in the report, and''
~~''(ii) support a [http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Moratorium_%28law%29 moratorium] on the construction of further wind turbines until the recommendations have been satisfactorily addressed.''"~~
''(ii) support a [http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Moratorium_%28law%29 moratorium] on the construction of further [http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wind_turbines wind turbines] until the recommendations have been satisfactorily addressed.''"
Senator Birmingham's amendment to this motion was:
"''That the Senate—''
''Omit subparagraph (b)(ii), so that paragraph (b) now reads:''
''(b) calls on the Government to immediately act on the committee's recommendations in the report.''"
References
* [1] Read the full report [http://aefweb.info/data/Senate%20Report%20on%20Wind%20Farms%20230611.pdf here] (2.7 MB). Read the Government's response to the report's recommendations [http://www.health.gov.au/internet/main/publishing.nsf/Content/36DB83157C4BE82FCA257BF0001B7544/$File/Wind%20Farm%20Response.pdf here] (344 KB). More information about the health concerns related to wind farms is available [http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wind_farms#Human_health here].

senate vote 2012-02-08#2

Edited by mackay staff

on 2014-04-15 16:16:41

Title

Description

The majority voted in favour of an [http://www.openaustralia.org/senate/?gid=2012-02-08.136.1 amendment] introduced by Senator [http://publicwhip-test.openaustraliafoundation.org.au/mp.php?mpn=Simon_Birmingham&mpc=Senate&house=senate Simon Birmingham].
The [http://www.openaustralia.org/senate/?gid=2012-02-08.135.2 original motion] that Senator Birmingham wanted to amend was introduced by Senator [http://publicwhip-test.openaustraliafoundation.org.au/mp.php?mpn=John_Madigan&mpc=Senate&house=senate John Madigan]. It was:
"''That the Senate—''
''(a) notes that on 23 June 2011 the [http://www.aph.gov.au/Parliamentary_Business/Committees/Senate/Community_Affairs Community Affairs References Committee] tabled its final report, Social and economic impact of rural wind farms containing seven recommendations, including recommendations calling for studies on the effects of wind farms on human health; and''[1]
''(a) notes that on 23 June 2011 the [http://www.aph.gov.au/Parliamentary_Business/Committees/Senate/Community_Affairs Community Affairs References Committee] tabled its final report,[1] Social and economic impact of rural wind farms containing seven recommendations, including recommendations calling for studies on the effects of wind farms on human health; and''
''(b) calls on the Government to:''
''(i) immediately act on the committee's recommendations in the report, and''
''(ii) support a [http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Moratorium_%28law%29 moratorium] on the construction of further wind turbines until the recommendations have been satisfactorily addressed.''"
Senator Birmingham's amendment to this motion was:
"''That the Senate—''
''Omit subparagraph (b)(ii), so that paragraph (b) now reads:''
''(b) calls on the Government to immediately act on the committee's recommendations in the report.''"
References
* [1] Read the full report [http://aefweb.info/data/Senate%20Report%20on%20Wind%20Farms%20230611.pdf here] (2.7 MB). Read the Government's response to the report's recommendations [http://www.health.gov.au/internet/main/publishing.nsf/Content/36DB83157C4BE82FCA257BF0001B7544/$File/Wind%20Farm%20Response.pdf here] (344 KB). More information about the health concerns related to wind farms is available [http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wind_farms#Human_health here].

senate vote 2012-02-08#2

Edited by mackay staff

on 2014-04-15 16:15:40

Title

~~Motions - Wind Farms - Act on the Community Affairs References Committee's recommentations~~
Motions - Wind Farms - Act on the Community Affairs References Committee's recommendations

Description

The majority voted in favour of an [http://www.openaustralia.org/senate/?gid=2012-02-08.136.1 amendment] introduced by Senator [http://publicwhip-test.openaustraliafoundation.org.au/mp.php?mpn=Simon_Birmingham&mpc=Senate&house=senate Simon Birmingham].
The [http://www.openaustralia.org/senate/?gid=2012-02-08.135.2 original motion] that Senator Birmingham wanted to amend was introduced by Senator [http://publicwhip-test.openaustraliafoundation.org.au/mp.php?mpn=John_Madigan&mpc=Senate&house=senate John Madigan]. It was:
"''That the Senate—''
''(a) notes that on 23 June 2011 the [http://www.aph.gov.au/Parliamentary_Business/Committees/Senate/Community_Affairs Community Affairs References Committee] tabled its final report, Social and economic impact of rural wind farms containing seven recommendations, including recommendations calling for studies on the effects of wind farms on human health; and''[1]
''(b) calls on the Government to:''
''(i) immediately act on the committee's recommendations in the report, and''
''(ii) support a [http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Moratorium_%28law%29 moratorium] on the construction of further wind turbines until the recommendations have been satisfactorily addressed.''"
Senator Birmingham's amendment to this motion was:
"''That the Senate—''
''Omit subparagraph (b)(ii), so that paragraph (b) now reads:''
''(b) calls on the Government to immediately act on the committee's recommendations in the report.''"
References
* [1] Read the full report [http://aefweb.info/data/Senate%20Report%20on%20Wind%20Farms%20230611.pdf here] (2.7 MB). Read the Government's response to the report's recommendations [http://www.health.gov.au/internet/main/publishing.nsf/Content/36DB83157C4BE82FCA257BF0001B7544/$File/Wind%20Farm%20Response.pdf here] (344 KB). More information about the health concerns related to wind farms is available [http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wind_farms#Human_health here].

senate vote 2012-02-08#2

Edited by mackay staff

on 2014-04-15 16:14:25

Title

~~Motions - Wind Farms - Act on Community Affairs References Committee's recommentations~~
Motions - Wind Farms - Act on the Community Affairs References Committee's recommentations

Description

The majority voted in favour of an [http://www.openaustralia.org/senate/?gid=2012-02-08.136.1 amendment] introduced by Senator [http://publicwhip-test.openaustraliafoundation.org.au/mp.php?mpn=Simon_Birmingham&mpc=Senate&house=senate Simon Birmingham].
The [http://www.openaustralia.org/senate/?gid=2012-02-08.135.2 original motion] that Senator Birmingham wanted to amend was introduced by Senator [http://publicwhip-test.openaustraliafoundation.org.au/mp.php?mpn=John_Madigan&mpc=Senate&house=senate John Madigan]. It was:
"''That the Senate—''
''(a) notes that on 23 June 2011 the [http://www.aph.gov.au/Parliamentary_Business/Committees/Senate/Community_Affairs Community Affairs References Committee] tabled its final report, Social and economic impact of rural wind farms containing seven recommendations, including recommendations calling for studies on the effects of wind farms on human health; and''[1]
''(b) calls on the Government to:''
''(i) immediately act on the committee's recommendations in the report, and''
''(ii) support a [http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Moratorium_%28law%29 moratorium] on the construction of further wind turbines until the recommendations have been satisfactorily addressed.''"
Senator Birmingham's amendment to this motion was:
"''That the Senate—''
''Omit subparagraph (b)(ii), so that paragraph (b) now reads:''
''(b) calls on the Government to immediately act on the committee's recommendations in the report.''"
References
* [1] Read the full report [http://aefweb.info/data/Senate%20Report%20on%20Wind%20Farms%20230611.pdf here] (2.7 MB). Read the Government's response to the report's recommendations [http://www.health.gov.au/internet/main/publishing.nsf/Content/36DB83157C4BE82FCA257BF0001B7544/$File/Wind%20Farm%20Response.pdf here] (344 KB). More information about the health concerns related to wind farms is available [http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wind_farms#Human_health here].
* [1] Read the full report [http://aefweb.info/data/Senate%20Report%20on%20Wind%20Farms%20230611.pdf here] (2.7 MB). Read the Government's response to the report's recommendations [http://www.health.gov.au/internet/main/publishing.nsf/Content/36DB83157C4BE82FCA257BF0001B7544/$File/Wind%20Farm%20Response.pdf here] (344 KB). More information about the health concerns related to wind farms is available [http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wind_farms#Human_health here].

senate vote 2012-02-08#2

Edited by mackay staff

on 2014-04-15 16:13:59

Title

~~Motions — Wind Farms~~
Motions - Wind Farms - Act on Community Affairs References Committee's recommentations

Description

~~John Madigan~~
~~I, and also on behalf of Senator Xenophon, move:~~
That the Senate—
  (a)   notes that on 23 June 2011 the Community Affairs References Committee tabled its final report, Social and economic impact of rural wind farms containing seven recommendations, including recommendations calling for studies on the effects of wind farms on human health; and
~~  (b)   calls on the Government to:~~
~~     (i)   immediately act on the committee's recommendations in the report, and~~
(ii)   support a moratorium on the construction of further wind turbines until the recommendations have been satisfactorily addressed.
Simon Birmingham
~~I seek leave to move an amendment to the motion.~~
~~Leave granted.~~
~~I move:~~
That the Senate—
~~Omit subparagraph (b)(ii), so that paragraph (b) now reads:~~
(b) calls on the Government to immediately act on the committee's recommendations in the report.
~~Rachel Siewert~~
I would like to be really clear because there has been some confusion around this motion. Are we amending the motion that was circulated that was actually in the Notice Paper? It is not the one that Senator Madigan was subsequently talking to people about?
~~Stephen Parry~~
We are dealing with the motion that would appear on the Notice Paper as No. 616. There is an amendment moved by Senator Birmingham to that notice. We cannot deal with a motion that we do not have before us, so it must be the one that is in the Notice Paper.
~~Rachel Siewert~~
So all we are doing now through this motion is supporting the implementation of the recommendations of the Community Affairs References Committee? I want to be really clear about what we are voting on.
~~Simon Birmingham~~
That is correct. This would delete and omit part (b)(ii) of motion No. 616 in the Notice Paper. That would leave the remaining part calling on the government to immediately act on the committee's recommendations in the report relating to wind farms.
~~John Madigan~~
~~Mr Deputy President, I seek leave to make a brief statement.~~
~~Stephen Parry~~
~~Leave is granted for two minutes.~~
~~John Madigan~~
The Senate inquiry into the social and economic impact of rural wind farms received more than 100,000 submissions and made only seven recommendations. It is now 7½ months later and not one of these recommendations has been implemented. I have been holding wind farm forums across the country and have been overwhelmed by the stories of families living close to turbines. I am calling for the government to act on the recommendations given by its own inquiry chaired by Senator Siewert. The motion also calls for a moratorium on the construction of any new wind turbines. This call is identical to the moratoriums that other parties have called for when the adverse health effects of new technologies have been raised. If there is no moratorium, there is no incentive to act. I am not a scientist. Perhaps the severe debilitating effects of wind farms can be solved by a simple engineering solution. I do not know. We need to stop the construction of any further wind turbines until we can study any problems and implement the recommendations that the Senate inquiry itself has made. Personal and community health need to be at the top of our concerns as elected representatives. Protecting and serving people is our prime reason for being in parliament.
~~Simon Birmingham~~
~~I seek leave to make a very short statement.~~
~~Stephen Parry~~
~~Leave is granted for two minutes.~~
Simon Birmingham
On behalf of the coalition—and I have explained what this amendment seeks to do—I say that we are very sympathetic to the issues that Senator Madigan has raised through this motion and that we do understand his concerns. Indeed, coalition senators—in particular, Senator Adams—have championed a number of these issues and concerns. We share Senator Madigan's concerns, and those of many in the community, that the government has not acted swiftly enough to implement the recommendations of this report. We hope that the Senate will pass the motion, brought forward by Senator Madigan in the amended terms, to try to increase the pressure on the government to do so. However, we do recognise that significant investments which have already been made and are in play would be impacted by a moratorium, and that would create a degree of business uncertainty. Unfortunately, that is why we find ourselves moving this amendment calling for the omission of a section of the motion.
~~Nick Xenophon~~
~~I seek leave to make a brief statement.~~
~~Stephen Parry~~
~~Leave is granted for two minutes.~~
~~Nick Xenophon~~
I support the remarks of Senator Madigan. I make it clear that I think wind farms are an important part of the renewable energy mix. But there are genuine community concerns, as witnessed by the Senate inquiry into this. There were seven unanimous recommendations which seem to be reasonable and measured. They take a precautionary approach to the concerns of communities about wind farms and to addressing these concerns by ensuring that the health effects and other matters are dealt with. I think they are quite reasonable recommendations. I think it makes sense that, if you think that the government should act on these recommendations— such as the recommendation that the NHMRC be involved in monitoring the health effects—then it is not unreasonable that there be a moratorium until the recommendations are acted on. The moratorium would not necessarily have to last very long, but it would be an incentive to ensure that the recommendations are acted upon and community concerns comprehensively dealt with once and for all. That is why I think it is important, given the context of the inquiry, for the moratorium to be supported as well as the recommendations.
~~John Hogg~~
~~The question is that the amendment moved by Senator Birmingham be agreed to.~~
~~The question now is that the motion, as amended, be agreed to.~~
~~Question agreed to.~~
The majority voted in favour of an [http://www.openaustralia.org/senate/?gid=2012-02-08.136.1 amendment] introduced by Senator [http://publicwhip-test.openaustraliafoundation.org.au/mp.php?mpn=Simon_Birmingham&mpc=Senate&house=senate Simon Birmingham].
The [http://www.openaustralia.org/senate/?gid=2012-02-08.135.2 original motion] that Senator Birmingham wanted to amend was introduced by Senator [http://publicwhip-test.openaustraliafoundation.org.au/mp.php?mpn=John_Madigan&mpc=Senate&house=senate John Madigan]. It was:
"''That the Senate—''
''(a) notes that on 23 June 2011 the [http://www.aph.gov.au/Parliamentary_Business/Committees/Senate/Community_Affairs Community Affairs References Committee] tabled its final report, Social and economic impact of rural wind farms containing seven recommendations, including recommendations calling for studies on the effects of wind farms on human health; and''[1]
''(b) calls on the Government to:''
''(i) immediately act on the committee's recommendations in the report, and''
''(ii) support a [http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Moratorium_%28law%29 moratorium] on the construction of further wind turbines until the recommendations have been satisfactorily addressed.''"
Senator Birmingham's amendment to this motion was:
"''That the Senate—''
''Omit subparagraph (b)(ii), so that paragraph (b) now reads:''
''(b) calls on the Government to immediately act on the committee's recommendations in the report.''"
References
* [1] Read the full report [http://aefweb.info/data/Senate%20Report%20on%20Wind%20Farms%20230611.pdf here] (2.7 MB). Read the Government's response to the report's recommendations [http://www.health.gov.au/internet/main/publishing.nsf/Content/36DB83157C4BE82FCA257BF0001B7544/$File/Wind%20Farm%20Response.pdf here] (344 KB). More information about the health concerns related to wind farms is available [http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wind_farms#Human_health here].